When Our Need for Control Gets in the Way of Learning
Thoughts on life, dog training, and learning to let go.
Hang on… this is long because I have been thinking about this a lot over the last few months. And I find it interesting that because I have been thinking about it, I see threads of this topic appearing in other posts and messages.
I’ve been thinking a lot lately about habits and how our need to control things affects our lives, our relationships, and especially how we train our dogs.
As humans, we’re naturally wired to seek some control over our environment. It helps us feel safe, comfortable, and secure. We want to understand what’s happening around us, anticipate what might happen next, and then attempt to influence the outcome. But at what point does our natural desire to control become something that works against us or causes issues with the people and animals in our lives?
I see this happening all the time in how dog trainers teach skills and behaviors. But I think it goes far beyond controlling the dog or the environment. It can show up in other ways and negatively affect our relationship with our dog and the trust we share.
When Our Dogs Become a Reflection of Ourselves
I think there are two different ways our desire for control can show up in our relationships with our dogs.
The first involves training, accomplishments, and success. We invest massive amounts of time, energy, and emotion into training our dogs. We want them to learn, succeed, and become the dogs we dreamed they could be. There’s nothing wrong with having goals or taking pride in our accomplishments. But what happens when our dog’s success becomes too closely connected to our own sense of worth? Do we begin to see their accomplishments as evidence of our value as trainers? Do we make their success a part of our identity, our status, or our sense of belonging within a community? And when training or trials don’t go well, do we start feeling as though we’ve failed as trainers?
Of course, then those feelings of failure hit our brains, and to feel better, we take stabs at other trainers. Negativity sets in because of how our minds work and our need for control.
What if we could see those moments for what they really are? Opportunities to learn and grow in more ways than training dogs.
Our dogs are learning. We’re learning. Sometimes things go well, and sometimes they don’t. Why do we need to make it so much more complicated than that?
Another way our desire for control shows up is through our concern for our dogs’ welfare. We worry about their physical health, emotional well being, behavior, and age related changes. We love them, and naturally, we want to believe they’ll be okay physically and emotionally. But sometimes we can’t know this for sure. We look for answers by asking questions. We seek reassurance from veterinarians, trainers, friends, and online communities about our research or findings (diet, health, emotions, etc.).
We push our beliefs on others to validate our findings. Seeking information and support is important. But what happens when we become dependent on reassurance to regulate our own emotions? When someone doesn’t respond, or doesn’t give us the answer we want, we may become increasingly worried, frustrated, or even angry. We keep searching for an answer that will make us feel better, or we push harder to get that validation.
But is it really the answer we’re looking for? Or are we trying to find some sense of control over an outcome we can’t guarantee? I wonder how often our concern for our dogs becomes tangled up with our own discomfort with uncertainty.
Enter Social Media, Technology, and the Illusion of Control
I believe technology has made research and information gathering easier, while also creating a more complex illusion of control. Social media unknowingly encourages us to look outside ourselves for feedback about our values. We post something and wait for responses. When no one (or only a few people) responds, we start to feel like people disagree. We can become so preoccupied with how others respond that we lose sight of why we shared something in the first place.
And now, with AI and instant access to seemingly endless information, it’s easy to believe that the right answer to almost any question is at our fingertips. We lose sight of the fact that there can be many different answers depending on the situation, beliefs, history, and other factors. We can keep searching, scrolling, asking, analyzing, and ruminating.
But having access to more information doesn’t necessarily give us more control. And it certainly doesn’t guarantee that we will feel more comfortable with uncertainty. Technology is wonderful when it is used in a way that supports our emotional stability. But it can also make it harder for us to accept that we can’t possibly know everything, control everything, or predict every outcome. We have to understand that there is no perfect answer. And we cannot control how other people think, feel, or respond. But we sure keep trying.
We Don’t Really Know What Others Are Thinking
Here’s another part of this puzzle that fascinates me. We spend an incredible amount of time trying to figure out what other people are thinking and feeling, which seems to matter far more than figuring out how we feel about it.
We interpret their words, actions, silence, and responses. We make assumptions based on our own experiences and emotions. Sometimes we think we understand someone because we believe we have a lot in common. We assume that we understand how they feel, but do we really? Even when we have similar experiences, no one interprets them the same way.
And the interesting part for me is that we don’t even understand or notice our own emotions when we assume we know how someone else feels. How often do we stop long enough to examine what we’re actually feeling, why we’re feeling it, and what we really need? Instead, we tend to spend our energy trying to get inside someone else’s head. What a waste of energy, and it risks depleting our emotional stability and confidence.
I think part of this is a natural human tendency, given how our minds work. They look for similarities and shared experiences because that helps us connect with others. We also try to anticipate what people are thinking so we can predict their behavior. Our minds love to prepare us for outcomes. But connecting with someone isn’t the same thing as knowing what they’re thinking. And understanding someone isn’t the same thing as attempting to control their responses, values, or emotions. What if we spent less time trying to interpret or influence other people’s reactions and more time understanding our own? This shift gives me immediate power and a true feeling of control and connection.
And all of this relates to our need to control the training/behavioral outcome and relationship with our own dog.
What Would Happen If We Let Go of Some Control?
This brings me to something I’ve been thinking about quite a bit. What if we learned to let go of some of our need for control?
I’m not suggesting we abandon responsibility, stop setting goals, or let our dogs do whatever they want. Good training requires planning, consistency, communication, and an understanding of dog behavior. There’s a difference between taking responsibility for the training process and needing to control every outcome.
We can control many of the choices and decisions we make as trainers, and those choices can change our dog’s behavior. We can decide how to structure a training session, how to respond when something goes wrong, how to manage the environment, and how to help our dog understand what we’re teaching. But we cannot guarantee exactly how or when learning will happen. We cannot control every distraction, every emotion, or every response, and we don’t need to.
What if we focused more on the process and less on proving that it’s working or that it is the only way to do something? What if we approached unexpected behavior with curiosity instead of frustration?
What if we could recognize our own emotional reactions without letting them determine what happens next or get in the way of our connection and relationship with our dog?
To me, this is part of learning to live in the present moment. It is one of the most challenging, but potentially most fulfilling changes we can make for our dog.
This change helps us accept that we don’t know everything, that we can’t predict every outcome, and that other living beings (including our dogs) have experiences and responses that aren’t entirely within our control. We can guide, support, and “listen to” them. When we do this, we learn from them.
Learning to Be Comfortable With Not Knowing
One of the most challenging things for humans is being comfortable with not knowing the answer or being able to solve a problem. We want to know that we’re doing things correctly and that everything will turn out okay. Can we learn to sit with that uncertainty, rather than trying to eliminate it? It’s not a personal failure when things are not going well.
We become better trainers, better friends, better family members, and better humans when we can quietly “listen”, observe, question our assumptions, regulate our own emotions, and be open to learning something new, even when that learning makes us uncomfortable.
So How Do We Change?
I keep coming back to the idea that we should develop skills to help us recognize when our desire for control is taking over. I’m not always aware that habit is taking over. As our dogs teach us every day, we need to learn to pause before reacting. They rarely, if ever, react. We need to become aware and recognize when we’re seeking information and when we’re really seeking reassurance.
And finally, we need to become more comfortable with the fact that learning, relationships, and life itself involve uncertainty.
Maybe the goal isn’t to give up control entirely. It might not be possible. Maybe it’s to learn the difference between what we’re responsible for and what we need to let go of. I don’t know the answer. But I think it’s worth thinking about.
What are your thoughts?


0 Comments